Here's Our Definitive Ranking of Every Reese's Peanut Butter Candy

Reese's Peanut Butter cups are one of the most beloved and classic candies, right up there with Hershey's. It's agreed upon by all that chocolate and peanut butter are the most amazing combination, and Reese's candies prove this again and again. Although we all know how tasty a good Reese's is, we probably have different opinions about which Reese's candy is the best. Here's our ranking of all 63 of the Reeses Peanut Butter candies! Do you agree?

63. White Crème Pink Hearts

White Crème Pink Hearts are just too far from the real deal. I don't know about you, but I don't approve of white crème surrounding my creamy peanut butter. Plus, the strange pink color just isn't what I look for in a candy.

62. White Pumpkins

Reese's White Pumpkins aren't terrible, they're just not as good as the more classic candies.

61. White Chocolate Eggs

These Easter-themed Reese's candies are also decent, but the white chocolate just doesn't go as well with peanut butter as milk chocolate or dark chocolate.

60. White Peanut Butter Cups

These are getting closer to the classic Reese's Peanut Butter cups we know and love, but the white chocolate still just doesn't compare.

59. White Chocolate Miniatures

The White Chocolate Minis are tasty and stackable, but just don't "wow" me.

58.  White Trees

Another white chocolate product, these nature-themed Reese's are full of white crème, and we love their fun shape.

57. White Crème Hearts

These are pretty darn cute, especially around Valentine's Day. However, no white crème product will match up with the classics.

56. White Mini Cups

These are the smallest size of Reese's, which is fun. They're about half peanut butter and half white chocolate, yummy for a sweet treat.

55. Ghosts

Reese's Peanut Butter ghosts are cute and Halloween-y, which is why they beat out most of the other white chocolate candies.

54. Snack Mix

The Snack Mix sounds delicious when you list it all out- peanuts, pretzels, pieces, and mini cups- but there's just a bit too much going on.

53. Pastel Egg Pieces

These Pastel Egg Pieces are tasty, and have a crunchier shell than our basic Reese's Pieces, but they need a bit more chocolate to really stand up to the competition.

52. Crunchers

Crunchers are a combo of rice puffs, peanuts, mini peanut butter chips, and milk chocolate. They're a good snack, but the texture is just not quite right.

51. 1-pound Bunny

This 1-pound bunny is perfect for an easter egg hunt. A peanut butter chocolate bunny would've been my dream as a kid on Easter! However, this one needs a bit more chocolate to balance out the peanut butter.

50. 8-ounce Hearts

This giant peanut-butter chocolate heart is delectable, but it's far bigger than the candy I'd prefer to snack on.

49. 6-ounce Egg

Similarly, the 6-ounce Reese's Peanut Butter egg is just too big to be that sweet treat you're looking for.

48. 5-ounce Hearts

The 5-ounce hearts are definitely better than the 8-ounce ones, but these still just aren't the cups of joy that Reese's Peanut Butter Cups deliver.

47. 5-ounce Reester Bunny

The 5-ounce Reester Bunny has the flavors of creamy peanut butter and chocolate, in a lovable bunny form.

46. Bells

Bells are a fun shape, and have lots of chocolate compared to the peanut butte they contain. For chocolate lovers, this is a wonderful thing.

45. Mini Cups

Mini cups are the ideal snack for Reese's lovers looking for just a bite of yumminess.

44. Eggs Stuffed With Pieces

The Eggs Stuffed With Pieces are trying to do a lot at once, but it works. Everything you need to know is in the name.

43. Trees Stuffed With Pieces

These are the same as the eggs, in tree form. They're tasty, like all Reese's peanut butter products, but there are better options.

42. Milk Chocolate Thins

Milk Chocolate Thins are like a thinner version of the classic cups, with more chocolate than peanut butter. They're yummy, but a bit lacking in the peanut butter department.

41. Crispy Crunchy Bar

For those who enjoy the crunch texture when added to the creamy peanut butter and chocolate, these are a decent choice.

40. Nutrageous Bar

The Nutrageous Bar seems to be the Snickers of Reese's. Creamy Hershey's chocolate, peanuts and caramel is such a good combo.

39. Trees

Reese's trees go back to the classic peanut-butter chocolate combo, but in a fun shape. The peanut butter-chocolate ratio is perfect.

38. Dark Chocolate Thins

The Dark Chocolate Thins are decent, but they do seem to contain more chocolate than peanut butter. Plus, why would we want a "thin" Reese's?

37. Hearts (Slender)

These thinner versions of Reese's Hearts are good, but I do miss the classic Reese's cup shape.

36. Eggs

Reese's eggs have a great ratio of chocolate and peanut butter, and they allow you to enjoy Easter any time of year.

35. Snack Size Hearts

You gotta love a bite-sized candy. These can be enjoyed in one bite, which is so satisfying and not to be overlooked.

34. Fast Break Bar

This seems like the Milky Way of Reese's, and we're not mad about it. Chewy nougat, peanut butter and milk chocolate just couldn't be a bad thing.

33. Outrageous Bar

The Outrageous Bar is basically the Nutrageous bar with full-size Reese's pieces, and it's incredibly addicting.

32. Popped Snack Mix

The Popped Snack Mix is a combo of Mini Cups, Pieces, peanuts, pretzels, and chocolate-drizzled popcorn. There's a lot going on, but it works.

32. Reester Bunnies

This Reester Bunny is more approachable than his larger counterpart, and is even creamier and delicious.

30. Hearts Stuffed With Pieces

Reese's Hearts Stuffed with Pieces are definitely combining a few different Reese's candies, but their efforts pay off, as these crunchy, chocolatey hearts are perfect for snacking.

29. 5-ounce Bunny

Yet another bunny, this one contains an amazing swirl of peanut butter and chocolate, somehow even creamier than normal.

28. Big Cups

If you're looking for all the goodness of a regular Reese's Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, but you want a bigger portion, this one's where it's at. Just like a king size chocolate bar, sometimes you just want more.

27. Eyeballs

These are perfect for trick or treat candies, as they bring all the spookiness you need along with delectable flavors.

26. Monster Mania

These are also a super fun option for Halloween candy, with their mummies and skulls.

25. Pumpkins

Reese's pumpkins are not only adorable, they're delicious! And so perfect for fall-time.

24. Dark Miniature Cups

I personally love dark chocolate, so these Dark Miniature Cups are delicious. However, they're still not as good as the classic Milk Chocolate candies.

23. Dark Peanut Butter Cups

Bigger portions of dark chocolate and peanut butter could never be a bad thing, right?

22. Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed with Crunchy Cookies

This Reese's Peanut Butter cups candy is a new level of delectable. Essentially a peanut butter cup with a chocolate cookie inside! Reese knew what he was doing with this one.

21. Big Cups Stuffed with Pieces

Reese's definitely loves a combo. The Big Cups Stuffed With Pieces are for those looking for an intense experience, a mouthful of chocolate, peanut butter, and crunchy pieces.

20. Miniature Eggs

The miniature eggs are another surprisingly tasty Reese's product. They have a tasty layer of chocolate with delicious peanut butter inside, and many Reese's lovers believe that the Mini eggs have found the perfect ratio.

19. Sugar Free Miniature Cups

These taste exactly the same as the regular Miniature cups! Enjoy a sweet snack without all the sugar content.

18. Miniature Cups Stuffed with Crunchy Cookies

Gotta love the mixture of textures that these mini cups do so well. For a mini cup with a little something extra going on, these are the perfect snack.

17. Miniature Cups Stuffed with Pieces

Another mini cup with an extra crunch, this wonderful creation is as delicious as it sounds.

16. Big Cups Stuffed with Crunchy Cookie

These are another Reese's product stuffed with crunchy deliciousness. For a crunchy peanut butter snack, these are ideal.

15. Chocolate Lovers Peanut Butter Cups

For the Reese's lovers who are also a huge fan of chocolate, these are ideal.

14. Clusters

The Clusters are full of delicious flavors, maybe a cross between a Twix bar and a Reese's. The pecans add crunch, and caramel is amazingly sweet and smooth. Definitely a top pick!

13. Dipped Pretzels

It's fully established that pretzels are amazing when combined with chocolate and peanut butter, and these Dipped Pretzels are no exception.

12. Reese's Peanut Butter Lovers Cups

Made for ultimate peanut butter lovers, these are extra peanut buttery. These taste almost like peanut butter chocolate fudge, with an amazing creamy texture and sweet flavor.

11. Peanut Butter Crème Eggs

Peanut Butter Crème Eggs come in that fun, satisfying egg shape, and the Peanut Butter Crème inside is amazingly thick and creamy.

10. Hershey's Bar With Reese's Pieces

The Hershey Company and Reese's came together to create something amazing. The combo of creamy Hershey's milk chocolate and crunchy Reese's Pieces in this candy bar doesn't disappoint.

9. Sticks

These are almost like the Kit Kat of Reese's, and they're as good as they sound.

8. Mini Sticks

Mini Sticks are the perfect combo of milk chocolate and Reese's peanut butter, in crunchy, snackable bars.

7. Hearts (Squat)

The larger Reese's Hearts have a crunchy milk chocolate shell and creamy peanut butter interior. Made into a fun heart shape, and they're the perfect snack.

6. Big Cups with Pretzels

The Reese's Big Cups with Pretzels are crunchy, salty, and big enough to share. Pretzels just go so well with peanut butter and chocolate.

5. Miniature Cups

Miniature Cups are tiny and satisfying, ideal for a quick sweet treat.

4. Reese's Pieces

Reese's Pieces are an obvious choice when looking at the top Reese's products. Peanut butter candy covered in a crunchy candy shell is too delicious.

3. Peanut Butter Cups Stuffed with Pieces

The classic peanut butter cups, but with an added crunchy twist. Yum!

2. Take 5

Take 5 bars are full of peanut butter, chocolate, caramel, pretzels, and peanuts, and Reese's does it right. So crunchy, chewy, and addicting!

1. Peanut Butter Cups

Don't fix what's not broken, right? Creamy peanut butter and chocolate in a satisfying cup shape is all we really need from Reese's.

Related Videos